Let’s start with some assumptions about the evangelical view of God, Heaven, and Hell:
- God is loving and wants all humans to go to Heaven
- Because God is just, he cannot allow sinners who haven’t been redeemed to be saved
- Although Jesus’ forgiveness is freely granted to all, those who do not accept it will not go to Heaven but will go to Hell
- Hell is eternal conscious torment (most often discussed as eternal burning in a lake of fire)
If you ask them doctrinally, Christians almost universally agree that Jews are going to Hell when they die. Although Christians are very supportive of Jews as God’s chosen people and Israel as a nation, they think Jews who don’t accept Jesus as the Messiah are Hell-bound.
So what happens if we assume that the Christians are right in their beliefs? Any Jews who were forced into Hitler’s ovens to be killed would immediately upon death find themselves in God’s oven (Hell). But whereas they could escape Hitler’s oven by dying, there is no escape from God’s oven.
So the logical implication is clear. Which is worse? Hitler’s oven or God’s? And is either one justice or an atrocity?